Tag Archives: reuben

Classic Reuben Sandwich


Classic Reuben Sandwich // Money Savvy Living


St. Patrick’s Day will be here soon… and I literally can’t get by this holiday without craving a good corned beef sandwich!  Of course, they are delicious any time of year, but it’s just like turkey at Thanksgiving, cookies at Christmas…and corned beef for St. Patrick’s Day.


While the corned beef brisket with potatoes, macaroni and cheese, or some other comfort food is tasty, I have to say that my very favorite way to eat corned beef is in a classic reuben sandwich!  Oh my…. so good.


Of course, you can buy a delicious reuben sandwich, but it is so easy to make, you won’t even need to find an Irish Pub in order to get that authentic taste…


Yes, it’s easy, but it will take some time if you’re going to cook your own corned beef bristketbut I did include a shopping list with a quicker option below as an alternative option.


So to start, cover a 2-3 pound corned beef in a crockpot with water, add the seasoning packet (and a bay leaf, if you want, but don’t forget to remove it later).  Cook for 6-8 hours, or until tender.  Meat should easily pull apart.  You can cook it on the stop top or in the oven, I just prefer a crockpot because it is so easy to just put on before work, then when you get home, most of dinner is ready!  Easy-peasy!


Next is the sauerkraut.  I never, ever just warm up sauerkraut from the jar or the bag (for me, that is just a little too sauer!).  I always like to cook it down for a few minutes with applesauce and brown sugar, and a little salt and pepper to taste.  This literally takes less than 5 minutes…


While that is cooking, you can butter your rye & pumpernickel bread and toast it on a griddle, put the provolone cheese (ok, so this is a twist on the “classic” reuben because my kids don’t like swiss cheese) on to melt on one side of the sandwich, and generously apply the Thousand Island dressing to the other side of the sandwich.  Pull the bread off the griddle because you are ready for a plate!


Layer on the thin chuncks of corned beef, top with sauerkraut, and you now have the most delicious reuben sandwich… oh yeah, seriously mouth-wateringly delicious!


Classic Reuben Sandwich // Money Savvy Living

Classic Reuben Sandwich

  • Corned beef
  • Sauerkraut
  • Thousand Island dressing
  • Rye & Pumpernickel bread
  • Provolone Cheese

Layer ingredients, hot or cold, to make a delicious sandwich!

*if you don’t have Thousand Island dressing, you can just mix some mayo, ketchup, and pickle relish together and you will have a great homemade Thousand Island dressing!



Shopping List

*Follow the instructions for this one-step rapid roast.  Preparation for it would be different than cooking a raw corned beef brisket.



*This post contains affiliate links. Should you choose to buy a product through here, I would receive a commission, but it does not change the price to you, the consumer.